Return to Granny's Query index

Granny's Advice

By Rosaleen Dickson, BA, MJ
Dear Great Granny.

I have a real problem with my mother-in -law. She is a good hearted person but is absolutely filthy as far as her own hygiene and her home are concerned.

It doesn't make sense to me how anyone could live that way. She lives out of state (Thank God)! The last time she visited my husband had to MAKE her take a shower. Even after she took her shower she still smelled like a sweaty underarm and it made me wonder if she even bothered to use soap.Then she made a comment about how she needed to get into the habit of brushing her teeth. The woman is 50 years old!!! She should have been in that habit at least by age three!!! The woman has a college degree and is very active in her community and her church. She goes out every week and gets her hair and nails done and doesn't care about her own personal hygiene??? I just don't get it.

Another thing when she has visited she has this very bad habit of passing gas and burping---Constantly! It makes me sick and very angry that a woman would act this way. She usually just laughs it off and says "There's more room out than there is in." I have gotten really angry and told her off before but all she said was "I don't care what people think of me." "If they don't like who I am they are just jealous." -----Hardly so in my case.

I have a 21 month old son that I don't want exposed to this type of behavior because it is bad manners and just plain unacceptable. Kids are very impressionable. I am beginning to wonder if she just isn't wrapped too tight. It's like she has no cooth about what she does or how she acts. My husband is also a slob but he is mentally stable. Unfortunately, he shares her philosophy about not caring what people think.

I just get tired of this lady and her son telling me that I am "Picky" just because I want a clean and neat house. The last time we went to my mother-in law's home, my son's white socks were black on the bottom after walking around her house. The inside of her refrigerator has black condensation instead of the normal "clear." Her dishes are always stacked to the ceiling. Her windows are so dirty you can't see out of them. It is just so nasty!!! When she washes her dishes I have seen her just rince them off with warm water and put them in the drying rack---she doesn't even use soap to wash her dishes!!! I am afraid to eat there or ask for a glass of water. I brought paper cups last time. And I insisted that we eat out at this nice restaurant that she is always talking about.

This is my husbands mom and my son's grandmother. I do not want to hold a grudge toward her for the rest of my life. What can I do???

Help!

Dear "Picky"

Well my dear, you have got a lot off your chest with that letter and I sure hope you feel better because of it.

Things you wish you could say to your husband and his mother have now been said to me. Good for you! Putting it all into words is a big help. When I receive these letters all I can do is assume that they are truthful, or at least partially so. I never get the letter which might be written by the other side of the issue. I wonder what your husband would be saying to me, if he were to write.

Anyway, my reply is to you and it won't be what you expected because my premise is that you can never change anyone else. You tell me your husband is a slob. So be it. You married a slob and now you are worried about raising a child in an environment which includes him and his equally "filthy" mother.

Sorry to say, that's exactly what you have to do, other than leaving your home and taking your child with you, and I do NOT advocate that.

The world is full of slobs and people who don't use soap to shower or in the dish pan. Your child will have to cope with these people through his life, and also will have to cope with the people who follow the TV ads and spend most of their time scrubbing themselves and everything else. Eventually he will find his own level and do what he wants. Hopefully it will meet with your approval, but be prepared for him to be a slob like his old man.

As for you, it seems to be a great hardship for you to put up with the differences between you and your mother-in-law. Unless you are willing to ignore her burping and farting and look the other way when she is stacking her dishes, you should stay away from her as much as possible. I'd be willing to bet that she is as annoyed by what she claims is your picky attitude as you are with her carelessness.

Many folks are so preoccupied with other matters that they honestly do not care what people think. Those whom I've known have been artists, writers, journalists, musicians, printers, engineers, builders, scientists, athletes, professors, and a whole bunch of other high achievers. Try to see beyond the outward appearance, and if she smells like an armpit, forget it. Sweat is not a sin. Soap is not the key to heaven. Mothers in law can be found to be genuinely wonderful people if you can just let yourself look for the good and stop worrying about the inside of her refrigerator.

Your child won't be tainted by his grandmother's seeming slovenliness. But he could be enriched by knowing her on some other level. Next time you sit down to write an essay about her, concentrate on everything that she does or has ever done that is praiseworthy. I'll bet it will be a difficult exercise, but when you've done it, save your essay to show your grandson when he is a teenager.

My best advice to you is to never mention anything adverse about your mother-in-law in conversation with your son, with your husband, with your mother-in-law, or with anyone else. Things only get worse the more you discuss them. And next time she farts in public, pretend you didn't hear it.

Yours sincerely,
GG


Return to Granny's Query index

www.ask-great-granny.comMy partners recommended site for SMS Games Loads of SMS Java Games for all popular makes of mobile
Lots of Free ring tones for Nokia phones click on the link to get your Free Ring Tones.
Get FREE POLYPHONIC RINGTONES click on the link for Free Polyphonic Ring Tones.
The site owners favourite ringtone site Provides ringtones for sharp mobiles in poly phonic format.